Skip to main content
← All Fed Slop Issues

27. Officer Goforth's midnight vehicle stop

Attributed claims only

Nothing on this page claims that Officer Goforth, Agent David Hull, or any other officer invented, altered, or misstated anything. Tyler Robinson is claimed to be the shooter; he is charged, not convicted, has not entered a guilty plea, and is presumed innocent. The questions below are about gaps in the public record, not accusations against any person.

The issue in plain words​

About twelve hours after Charlie Kirk was killed at Utah Valley University, a gray Dodge Challenger reportedly pulled up to the corner of Campus Drive and 800 South, on the edge of campus. A Spanish Fork police officer named Goforth, working security that night, spoke with the driver for a short time. Hearing coverage describes the contact as roughly 20 seconds.

The prosecution uses that contact, placed at about 12:30 AM on September 11, 2025, to put Tyler Robinson back in Orem after midnight. It is the only item in the public record that puts his car at UVU after dark with a named officer attached. The full hearing exchange is on The Goforth Midnight Stop.

The trouble is timing. Staff at Cowboy's Smokehouse in Panguitch, about 209 road miles south, say a man they recognized as Robinson paid for dinner at 9:47 PM the same night. Both accounts cannot comfortably be true on an ordinary drive. That collision is Chain: Panguitch breaks the evening.

Side by side​

Fed Slop SideAnother pin on Robinson in the north valley after the shooting. Supports the Orem-home timeline.
Citizen InvestigatorsCollapses if the Panguitch receipt is his. Either the stop involved a different car or person, or the phone-and-car timeline has a gap nobody has explained.

The fed slop side, in full​

The official-side argument is simple and, stated fairly, it has a real hook. An officer saw a car trying to get back onto campus after midnight, felt something was off, and wrote down part of the plate. When the case broke, he ran it, and the registration came back to Tyler Robinson and a relative. That is independent of the family bringing Robinson in, and it came before the surrender. It also fits the messages the state says were recovered about retrieving the rifle from the wooded area once police left.

On Day 2 of the July 2026 preliminary hearing, Agent David Hull walked the court through State's Exhibit 12. The last clip, as he described it, shows a vehicle at Campus Drive and 800 South attempting to turn onto campus. Hull said Officer Goforth, Spanish Fork Police, was on security detail. The contact was "approximately 0:30, 12:30 a.m." on September 11. Hull's phrase for why Goforth made a note was "cop intuition." Two registered owners came back: Tyler Robinson and Amber Robinson. Hull said the driver was a male Goforth "believed" to be Robinson.

The same night, Hull testified, a Ring doorbell at the Noble household showed a vehicle consistent with Robinson's Challenger parking at about 12:38 AM, with a later departure around 1:33–1:35 AM. License-plate readers later put plate T455CE in Cedar City at about 7:16 AM. On this view the Panguitch story is a mistaken identification, and the stop is one more pin in a timeline that already holds: Orem after midnight, then south toward Washington County in the morning. Official-side commentators treated the hearing clip as a closed identification of the car and the driver.

What citizen investigators say​

Investigators point first to how thin the record is. Officer Goforth did not testify. Everything the court heard came from Hull relaying what Goforth told him, on Day 2. He said Goforth ran a "partial plate" only after a vehicle "or a vehicle matching the description" was linked to the case. No bodycam clip, written stop report, citation, or field-interview card was shown. There is no statement about what the driver said.

On cross-examination, defense attorney Kathryn Nester had Hull confirm that the Noble household, which supplied Ring doorbell video of the car, told investigators the driver was bald and that three other people were in the car. Robinson is not bald, and the state's account has him alone. Project Constitution posted the Ring clip the same day and called the quality too grainy to carry the identification.

Then there is the drive. From a 9:47 PM card approval in Panguitch, a normal drive to Orem takes about 3 hours 9 minutes to 3 hours 40 minutes, arriving roughly 12:56 to 1:27 AM. Reaching a 12:30 AM contact needs about 77 mph with no stops, starting on two-lane US-89 during a statewide manhunt. Investigators say that is not strictly impossible, but it is not the evening the state describes. Either the Panguitch customer was someone else, the Goforth driver was someone else, or the night-of timeline has a hole. The Cowboy's Smokehouse receipt is the other clock. The 25-hour driving day is what the state's story requires if every pin is his.

Citizen investigators also note that gray Challengers are not unique. Footage from KSL's live broadcast on September 10 shows at least one gray Challenger in the exit line after the shot. That does not prove a decoy. It does mean a partial plate plus "cop intuition," without the officer on the stand, is a thin way to lock a capital identification. Candace Owens has walked the same clock in public: if the Panguitch card is his, he is not behind the wheel when Goforth stops that car at midnight, he is not the bald man at 12:38, and he is not starting a Maps route off the Noble street at 1:33 AM.

The Cedar City Maverik stop the next morning, around 7:15–7:17 AM, is a separate pin. See Cedar City Maverik. It sits on the southbound I-15 run toward Washington County. It does not rescue a 12:30 AM Orem contact if the 9:47 PM Panguitch ticket is his. The longer write-up is Panguitch — the town that breaks the timeline.

When this fight ran​

  • 25 September 2025. National outlets reported that Robinson had circled back near the rifle drop and "made contact" with an officer. No named officer yet in most of that coverage.
  • January 2026. The Panguitch steakhouse story went national. That is when the midnight-Orem pin and the 9:47 PM receipt first collided in public.
  • 7 July 2026. Day 2 of the preliminary hearing. Hull names Officer Goforth, 12:30 AM, partial plate, "cop intuition." Live blogs (East Idaho News, Post Millennial) ran the clip in real time.
  • 11 July – 11 August 2026. Citizen investigators argued the stop was a late insert to hold the Orem-home timeline. Project Constitution called the named encounter a detail that appeared only at the hearing.

Why it matters for Tyler Robinson​

The stop carries the whole post-midnight half of the state's timeline, including the rifle-retrieval story. If the Panguitch receipt is his, the stop cannot be him on any normal drive, and a key independent identification becomes a second-hand belief about a partial plate. If a central identification can be this thin here, readers are entitled to ask what else in the package rests on the same kind of footing. That is why Proof Not Tyler treats geography as a test, not a color item.

What would settle it​

  • Officer Goforth's own report, notes, and bodycam for the contact, and his sworn testimony.
  • The partial plate exactly as written, and the full list of vehicles it returned.
  • The native video file for the final clip of State's Exhibit 12, with its embedded timestamp.
  • The Noble interview report and the full Ring export with metadata.
  • Bank records for the Visa debit card that paid the Panguitch check, plus phone location data for the evening.
  • A public match or mismatch on the last-four card digits. Until that comparison is made, the collision stays a collision.

Read more on this site​