Skip to main content
← Table drill-downs

The Erika rows the archives cannot decide

Where this came from. On the Following overview, the two-ledger table — the one that separates the Charlie Kirk and Turning Point claims from the Erika Kirk claims and scores each against recovered position data — has a right-hand column headed "Archives cannot answer." On the Erika Kirk line that cell reads "39 (+1 names no aircraft)" and links here. This page is that cell, opened. It holds 41 rows, not 40, and the difference is explained below rather than papered over.

The rest of the Erika line reads: 56 claimed, 12 corroborated, 3 refuted. Twelve plus three plus these forty-one is fifty-six, which is the whole ledger. Twelve plus three plus forty is fifty-five, which is one short — so the count on this page is the one that reconciles.

What this slice is

A row is in this list when the compilers' sheet claims Erika Kirk, the row carries a date, and the recovered position data decides nothing about it. Four verdicts land in that bucket, and three of the four are limits of the archive rather than statements about the aircraft:

  • Not heard — 29 rows. The free volunteer archives cover that date and served other airframes on it, but hold no trace at all for this one.
  • No archive coverage — 10 rows. No free archive reaches that date for any airframe probed, including the control aircraft with no connection to this case.
  • No aircraft named — 1 row. The claim names no tail number, so there is no airframe to look up.
  • Right area, wrong field — 1 row. The airframe was tracked and its closest recovered position is 28 km from the named airport — inside the sheet's own stated tolerance, outside a same-airport test.

Reproduce the list from overlaps.csv by taking every dated row whose Erika Present column reads claimed and whose Charlie Present column reads not_claimed, then keeping those whose ADS-B verdict is neither AT_CLAIMED_AIRPORT nor ELSEWHERE. Two exclusions are built into the ledger itself and both matter. The nine rows claiming both Kirks are scored on the Charlie and TPUSA ledger instead, because Charlie is the half of those rows that is documented. The five undated rows are excluded because an undated claim cannot be put to an archive at all; they sit in the five never-published rows. Sixty-one Erika-alone rows minus those five undated rows is the 56 this ledger scores.

Where the 41 and the 40 diverge. The overview cell counts the 29 Not heard plus the 10 No archive coverage as its "39", then adds the 1 row naming no aircraft in brackets. The Right area, wrong field row — OWENS-012, SU-BTT at Wichita on 14 April 2023, closest recovered position 27.58 km from KICT — is undecided by exactly the same standard but is not in the overview's bracketed arithmetic. Both figures are printed here. The register's own total of 56 says 41 is the right one for this bucket.

At a glance

Rows41 — the overview cell prints 39 (+1); see the note above
Distinct dates39 — two dates carry two rows each: 12 January 2025 (OWENS-031, OWENS-061) and 7 July 2025 (OWENS-037, OWENS-066)
Date range5 October 2022 to 11 July 2025. Every row in this slice carries a date.
AircraftSU-BTT 32 · SU-BND 8 · aircraft unknown 1
AirportsKICT Wichita 10 · KOMA Omaha 7 · KILG Wilmington 6 · KPVU Provo 5 · KSTL St. Louis 4 · KLNK Lincoln 2 · KORD Chicago 2 · one row each at KATL, KBGR, KBOS, KJFK, KSMF
StatesKS 10 · NE 9 · DE 6 · UT 5 · MO 4 · IL 2 · one row each in CA, GA, MA, ME, NY
By year2022: 9 · 2023: 11 · 2024: 13 · 2025: 8
ADS-B verdictNot heard 29 · No archive coverage 10 · No aircraft named 1 · Right area, wrong field 1
Tracking-site audit verdictInaccurate 34 · Accurate 4 · Not assessable, archive gap 2 · Not reached by the audit 1
Who the sheet claimsErika Kirk alone — 41 of 41. Charlie Kirk — 0.
Ground-position confirmations0 of 41
Rows falling on a day this site independently sources a Kirk or TPUSA appearance4 of 41
Erika Kirk's presence established0 of 41

TABLE A — the following aircraft

RowDate claimedAirportCity / StateFollowing aircraftTypeICAO hexArrived fromDeparted toGround stay logged, arrivedDepartedDaysTransponder / ground flagADS-B verdictClosest approach
OWENS-0015 October 2022KJFK
New York area (claimed)
New York, NYSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Cairo via Parisnot recordedno logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-00220 October 2022KORD
Chicago area (claimed)
Chicago, ILSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3New York via Parisnot recordedno logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-0031 November 2022KBOS
Boston area (claimed)
Boston, MASU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Chicago via Parisnot recordedno logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-00413 November 2022KICT
Wichita Dwight D. Eisenhower National
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Cairo via ParisWilmington DE 2022-11-17no logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-00517 November 2022KILG
Wilmington New Castle
Wilmington, DESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3WichitaCairo (sheet said 11/17; audit says 11/20)no logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-04325 November 2022KILG
Wilmington (claimed)
Wilmington, DESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-0445 December 2022KORD
Chicago (claimed)
Chicago, ILSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-00620 December 2022KSTL
St. Louis Lambert / Downtown / Spirit (sheet says St. Louis)
St. Louis, MOSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Cairo via ParisBangor ME 2022-12-27no logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-00727 December 2022KBGR
Bangor International
Bangor, MESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3St. LouisCairo (back 2023-01-03 per audit)no logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-04512 January 2023KICT
Wichita (claimed)
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-00815 January 2023KATL
Atlanta (claimed)
Atlanta, GASU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Cairo via Parisnot recordedno logged stay covers this dateNo archive coverage
OWENS-00910 February 2023KILG
Wilmington (claimed)
Wilmington, DESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3AtlantaParis / Cairono logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-04715 March 2023KOMA
Omaha (claimed)
Omaha, NESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)not recordedno logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-04827 March 2023KILG
Wilmington (claimed)
Wilmington, DESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Omaha (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-01214 April 2023KICT
Wichita Dwight D. Eisenhower National
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Cairo via ParisWilmington 2023-04-20no logged stay covers this dateRight area, wrong field27.58 km
OWENS-0518 June 2023KICT
Wichita (claimed)
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-01612 June 2023KPVU
Provo Municipal (claimed)
Provo, UTSU-BNDGulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree)01003EProvo (claimed)Paris / SLC (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-05225 June 2023KILG
Wilmington (claimed)
Wilmington, DESU-BNDGulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree)01003EWilmington (claimed)Paris / Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-01725 July 2023KLNK
Lincoln (claimed)
Lincoln, NESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Cairo via Parisnot recordedno logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-0183 September 2023KILG
Wilmington (claimed)
Wilmington, DESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Lincoln (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-01910 January 2024KSMF
Sacramento (claimed)
Sacramento, CASU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Cairo via Parisnot recordedno logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-05310 March 2024KSTL
St. Louis (claimed)
St. Louis, MOSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-02218 March 2024KICT
Wichita (claimed)
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)not recordedno logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-05422 March 2024KICT
Wichita (claimed)
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Wichita (claimed)Wilmington / Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-05515 April 2024KOMA
Omaha (claimed)
Omaha, NESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-0563 May 2024KSTL
St. Louis (claimed test flight)
St. Louis, MOSU-BNDGulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree)01003Enot recordednot recorded19 April 202412 July 202484Not heard
OWENS-05710 May 2024KSTL
St. Louis (claimed)
St. Louis, MOSU-BNDGulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree)01003EMissouri (claimed)Paris / Cairo (claimed)19 April 202412 July 202484Not heard
OWENS-05818 June 2024KLNK
Lincoln (claimed)
Lincoln, NESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Wilmington / Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-0595 July 2024KICT
Wichita (claimed)
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Wichita (claimed)Wilmington / Paris (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-02820 July 2024KOMA
Omaha then Lincoln (claimed)
Omaha / Lincoln, NESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Cairo via ParisWilmington / Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-06025 July 2024KOMA
Omaha then Lincoln (claimed)
Omaha / Lincoln, NESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Wilmington / Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-02917 August 2024KOMA
Omaha then Lincoln (claimed)
Omaha / Lincoln, NESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Wilmington / Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-0308 December 2024KPVU
Provo (claimed)
Provo, UTSU-BNDGulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree)01003EProvo (claimed)Paris / SLC (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-03112 January 2025KICT
Wichita (claimed)
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-06112 January 2025KICT
Wichita (claimed)
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-03217 January 2025KICT
Wichita (claimed)
Wichita, KSSU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)not recordedno logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-0628 February 2025KOMA
Omaha (claimed)
Omaha, NESU-BTTDassault Falcon 7X0101D3Paris (claimed)Cairo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-06419 April 2025KPVU
Provo (claimed)
Provo, UTSU-BNDGulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree)01003EProvo (claimed)Paris / SLC / Provo (claimed)no logged stay covers this dateNot heard
OWENS-0377 July 2025KPVU
Provo (sheet said leaving; audit says still there)
Provo, UTSU-BNDGulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree)01003EProvo (actual)nowhere — still in Provo23 May 202513 September 2025113Not heard
OWENS-0667 July 2025KPVU
Provo (sheet said leaving)
Provo, UTSU-BNDGulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree)01003EProvonowhere — still in Provo23 May 202513 September 2025113Not heard
EXTRA-00411 July 2025KOMA
Omaha (claimed by amplifier, not Owens sheet)
Omaha, NEno tail namednot statednot recordednot recordedno logged stay covers this dateNo aircraft named

TABLE B — who they are claimed to have been following

RowDate claimedWho the sheet claims was presentErika location as the sheet gives itSourced Kirk / TPUSA appearance same dayVenueLocal timeNearest airport to that venueKirk-side aircraft on record
OWENS-0015 October 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNew YorkNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in NY that week (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: TPUSA — Live Free Tour — University of Delaware (Candace Owens), Newark, DE (-2 days)none recorded
OWENS-00220 October 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedIllinoisCharlie — Live Free Tour — Florida State University, Tallahassee, FLFlorida State UniversityKTLH — Tallahassee International, 5 minone recorded
OWENS-0031 November 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedMassachusettsNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in MA (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-00413 November 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansasNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Live Free UMKC Kansas City MO 2022-10-18 (25 days earlier, different state); Candace Owens Live Free UDelaware Newark DE 2022-10-03 (register: 25 days away)none recorded
OWENS-00517 November 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedDelawareNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Candace Owens Live Free UDelaware Newark 2022-10-03 (45 days earlier) (register: 45 days away)none recorded
OWENS-04325 November 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedDelawareNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie UNM Albuquerque 2022-11-30 (different state) (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-0445 December 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedIllinoisNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in IL Dec 2022 (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-00620 December 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedMissouriNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: AmericaFest 2022 Phoenix AZ 2022-12-17 to 2022-12-20 (different state, same days) (register: 0_different_state days away) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — AmericaFest 2022, Phoenix, AZ (-3 days)none recorded
OWENS-00727 December 2022Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimednever statedNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in Maine (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-04512 January 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansasNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in KS Jan 2023 (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-00815 January 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimednever statedNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in GA that week (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-00910 February 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedDelawareNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie at ASU Tempe 2023-02-08 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Health, Wealth and Happiness — ASU Gammage, Tempe, AZ (-2 days)none recorded
OWENS-04715 March 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNebraskaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Rutgers New Brunswick 2023-03-21 / Columbus 2023-03-22 (different states) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Live Free Tour — UC Davis, Davis, CA (-1 days)none recorded
OWENS-04827 March 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedDelaware / NebraskaCharlie — Live Free Tour — Texas Christian University, Fort Worth, TXTexas Christian UniversityKFTW — Fort Worth Meacham International, 5 minone recorded
OWENS-01214 April 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansasNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: TPUSA Faith Kingdom to the Capitol Topeka KS 2023-04-23 (register: 9 days away)none recorded
OWENS-0518 June 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansasNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: YWLS Grapevine TX 2023-06-09 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Young Women's Leadership Summit 2023, Grapevine, TX (+1 days)none recorded
OWENS-01612 June 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedUtahNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in UT in June 2023; Utah record on this site begins April 2024 (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Young Women's Leadership Summit 2023, Grapevine, TX (-3 days)none recorded
OWENS-05225 June 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedDelawareNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in DE June 2023 (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-01725 July 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNebraskaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie speaks Lincoln NE 2023-08-25 (31 days later; audit still places aircraft in Egypt that day too) (register: 31 days away)none recorded
OWENS-0183 September 2023Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedDelaware / NebraskaNone same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days.none recorded
OWENS-01910 January 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedCaliforniaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Restoring National Confidence Las Vegas 2024-01-29 to 2024-02-04 (different state, 19 days later) (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-05310 March 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedMissouriNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Cal Poly SLO 2024-03-07 / Fullerton 2024-03-14 (California) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Prove Me Wrong table — Cal Poly SLO, San Luis Obispo, CA (-3 days)none recorded
OWENS-02218 March 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansasCharlie — Live Free / Prove Me Wrong — San Diego State University, San Diego, CASan Diego State UniversityKSAN — San Diego International, 4 minone recorded
OWENS-05422 March 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansas / DelawareNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie UNLV 2024-03-21 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Campus event — UNLV, Las Vegas, NV (-1 days)none recorded
OWENS-05515 April 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNebraskaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Omaha Lord of Hosts 2024-04-09 (6 days earlier) — a real Charlie appearance with NO aircraft in Nebraska (register: 6 days away)none recorded
OWENS-0563 May 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedMissouriNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Seattle 2024-05-07 (different state) (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-05710 May 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedMissouriNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in MO May 2024 (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Prove Me Wrong tabling — UNLV, Las Vegas, NV (-2 days)none recorded
OWENS-05818 June 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNebraskaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: People's Convention Detroit 2024-06-14 (different state) (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-0595 July 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansas / DelawareNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in KS July 2024 (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-02820 July 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNebraskaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in NE July 2024 (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-06025 July 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNebraskaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie West Palm Beach 2024-07-24 and 2024-07-26 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Turning Point Academy Educators' Summit 2024, West Palm Beach, FL (-1 days)none recorded
OWENS-02917 August 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNebraskaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in NE Aug 2024 (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-0308 December 2024Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedUtahNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: AmericaFest 2024 Phoenix 2024-12-19 to 2024-12-24 (different state) (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-03112 January 2025Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansasNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Washington DC 2025-01-19 (different state) (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-06112 January 2025Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansasNone same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days.none recorded
OWENS-03217 January 2025Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedKansasNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in KS Jan 2025 (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Turning Point's Inaugural Eve Ball, Washington, DC (+2 days)none recorded
OWENS-0628 February 2025Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedNebraskaNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Phoenix 2025-02-18 (different state) (register, gap not stated)none recorded
OWENS-06419 April 2025Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedUtahNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Laramie 2025-04-24 (different state). SU-BGM WAS at Provo 2025-04-16 — different tail, not in the 73-tally. (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — American Comeback Tour — Texas A&M, College Station, TX (+3 days)none recorded
OWENS-0377 July 2025Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedUtahNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie SAS Tampa 2025-07-11 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Chapter Leadership Summit 2025, Tampa, FL (+2 days)none recorded
OWENS-0667 July 2025Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimedUtahNone same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: SAS Tampa 2025-07-11 (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Chapter Leadership Summit 2025, Tampa, FL (+2 days)none recorded
EXTRA-00411 July 2025Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimednever statedCharlie — TPUSA Student Action Summit 2025, Tampa, FLTampa Convention Center, 333 S Franklin St, Tampa, FLKTPA — Tampa International, 6 minone recorded

TABLE C — sourcing and both verdicts

RowSheet indexAudit verdict (tracking-site pass)ADS-B verdict (position data)What the position data saysSource of the claimSource postFull row page
OWENS-0011InaccurateNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit screenshots; Erika Location column reads New York on the visible extractpostopen
OWENS-0022InaccurateNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-0033InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsbexchange-samples served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-0044AccurateNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE); Owens Ep 268 Wilmington recappostopen
OWENS-0055InaccurateNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit; Owens Ep 268postopen
OWENS-04343Not assessable — archive gapNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (archive gap)postopen
OWENS-04444Not assessable — archive gapNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (archive gap)postopen
OWENS-0066AccurateNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE)postopen
OWENS-0077AccurateNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE)postopen
OWENS-04545InaccurateNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-0088InaccurateNo archive coverageSAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression.Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-0099InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN ABSENCE…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-04747InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-04848InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-01212AccurateRight area, wrong fieldRIGHT AREA, WRONG FIELD. Closest recovered position is 28 km from KICT - inside the source sheet's own 50-100 mile tolerance, outside a same-airport test. Neither confirmed nor refuted.Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE 4/14); Owens Ep 256 INFILTRATION (Sacramento 4/13 then Cairo-to-Kansas)postopen
OWENS-05151InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-01616InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-05252InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-01717InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-01818InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-01919InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit; @liztalny1023 19 Nov 2025 quoting the California cellpostopen
OWENS-05353InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-02222InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-05454InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-05555InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-05656InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-05757InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-05858InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-05959InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-02828InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-06060InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-02929InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-03030InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-03131InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-06161InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-03232InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-06262InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-06464InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-03737InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
OWENS-06666InaccurateNot heardSAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN…Owens sheet via Kanekoa auditpostopen
EXTRA-004Not reached by the auditNo aircraft namedThe claim names no tail number, so there is no airframe to look up. Untestable as published.@bfr1273 19 Aug 2026 citing a Stew Peters X post of 5 Aug 2026 and a guestpostopen

What the specifics show

This is the biggest single bucket in the Erika ledger — 41 of 56 rows, close to three in four — and it is the bucket where the evidence runs out rather than the bucket where it points anywhere. Nothing on this page is a finding about the aircraft. It is a record of what was asked and what came back empty, kept separate from what was never asked at all, because those two are not the same thing and merging them would be the easiest way to mislead a reader on this whole subject.

The 2022 rows fail for one reason and it is a calendar reason, not an aircraft reason. Eight of the nine 2022 rows come back No archive coverage, and so do the two earliest 2023 rows, OWENS-045 (12 January 2023) and OWENS-008 (15 January 2023). That is the full No-archive-coverage block: OWENS-001, OWENS-002, OWENS-004, OWENS-005, OWENS-043, OWENS-044, OWENS-006, OWENS-007, OWENS-045, OWENS-008 — ten claim dates spanning 5 October 2022 to 15 January 2023. The span is not quite unbroken: one row inside it, OWENS-003 at Boston on 1 November 2022, comes back Not heard rather than No archive coverage, so it is the single 2022 row in the Not heard block below. For the other ten, no free archive reaches back that far for any airframe, control aircraft included. That is the archive's retention boundary showing up at the front of the register, and it must not be read as anything having been removed.

From 2023 onward the failure mode changes to Not heard, and that is a different limitation. Twenty-nine rows — one in 2022, eight in 2023, all thirteen 2024 rows and seven of the eight 2025 rows — sit on dates the volunteer archives do cover, serving other aircraft, while holding no trace for the named airframe. Parked with the transponder switched off, sitting outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from outside. None of the three can be separated from the other two with the data on this page.

Wichita is the densest field in this slice and it is also the one with the clearest ordinary explanation. Ten of the 41 rows name KICT, spread across all four years — OWENS-004, OWENS-045, OWENS-012, OWENS-051, OWENS-022, OWENS-054, OWENS-059, OWENS-031, OWENS-061 and OWENS-032 — and the overview records Wichita as the home of Yingling Aviation, an FAA Part 145 Dassault Falcon service centre. Thirty-two of these 41 rows name SU-BTT, which is a Falcon 7X. A Falcon repeatedly visiting a Falcon service centre is the explanation that has to be disposed of first, and nothing in this slice disposes of it.

Four rows fall on a day this site can independently source a Kirk or TPUSA appearance, and all four put the aircraft in a different state from the one documented person. OWENS-002: jet claimed at Chicago, Charlie Kirk sourced at Florida State in Tallahassee. OWENS-048: Wilmington against Texas Christian in Fort Worth. OWENS-022: Wichita against San Diego State. EXTRA-004: Omaha against the Student Action Summit in Tampa. On none of the four is the aircraft in the same state as the sourced appearance, and on none of them is Erika Kirk sourced anywhere at all.

The people column is thinner here than in any other cut of this register. Across the 41 rows the sheet's Erika Location cell holds a single bare US state 34 times — Kansas 8, Nebraska 8, Utah 5, Delaware 4, Missouri 4, Illinois 2, and one each for California, Massachusetts and New York — names two places at once 4 times, and reads UNKNOWN 3 times. Not one of the 41 rows names a city, a venue or an address on her side. Ground-position confirmations across the whole slice: zero.

Two rows in this bucket are the same claim entered twice, and the register says so. OWENS-037 and OWENS-066 both put SU-BND departing Provo on 7 July 2025; the register's note on OWENS-066 records it as a duplicate of OWENS-037, and the note on OWENS-037 records the aircraft as parked while the sheet has it flying home. OWENS-031 and OWENS-061 are the other same-date pair, both at Wichita on 12 January 2025. Duplicated rows inflate a headline count without adding a single new date, which is why the distinct-date figure of 39 is printed beside the row count of 41 rather than behind it.

The audit and the archives are not measuring the same thing here, and it shows. The tracking-site audit reached a verdict on 38 of these 41 rows and called 34 of them inaccurate, working against paid flight-history archives that reach further back than any free one. It called four accurate — OWENS-004, OWENS-006 and OWENS-007, all three of which are in the free archives' 2022 blind spot, plus OWENS-012, the 28-km Wichita row. It marked two more not assessable for its own archive gap, and never reached EXTRA-004. Where the audit reached a verdict and the free archives could not, the audit's answer is the only one on the row — and it is an answer about the aircraft, never about a passenger.

What this list cannot tell you

  • Nothing on this page is evidence that anything was deleted. Not heard and No archive coverage are limits of free volunteer archives. The 10 No-archive-coverage rows failed for control aircraft with no connection to this case on the same dates and the same endpoint, which is what identifies them as a retention boundary rather than a removal. Neither verdict is suppression, and neither is evidence that the aircraft was somewhere else.
  • An absence is not a finding. A volunteer network hearing nothing means a volunteer network heard nothing. Transponder off, out of receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date are all live possibilities on every one of the 29 Not heard rows.
  • A trace locates an aircraft. It never places a person aboard. That limit binds hardest here, because on this page there is not even a trace — so no row on it can carry any weight at all about who was or was not travelling.
  • Erika Kirk's presence is established on zero of these 41 rows, and on zero rows anywhere in the register. Her flight logs are reported erased and no dated itinerary for her has been published by the compilers, by Turning Point USA, or by anyone else. Every row here rests on a spreadsheet cell naming a state.
  • An undecided row is not a half-corroborated row. Nothing on this page should be added to the 12 corroborations to make a larger supporting number. These 41 belong on neither side of the ledger, which is the whole reason the ledger has a third column.
  • No crime is asserted against anyone. The sheet is the compilers'; the audit verdicts are the auditor's; the ADS-B verdicts are this investigation's, measured off raw traces. The ordinary explanations the register carries — Yingling Aviation's Falcon service centre at Wichita, Duncan Aviation's Egyptian Air Force maintenance account at Lincoln and Provo, transatlantic customs and fuel stops at Wilmington — are printed on the rows themselves.
  • On the count, plainly. The overview cell prints 39 (+1 names no aircraft); this page holds 41. Both numbers are on this page. The 41 includes the Right area, wrong field row OWENS-012, which is undecided by the same standard as the rest, and only the 41 makes the Erika ledger add to its published total of 56. Note separately that the tracking-site audit worked from a 78-row version of the register while this register holds 85.

Flight-record pages for what is on this page

This investigation keeps one page per airport and one page per recorded ground contact, built directly from the recovered ADS-B traces. These are the ones this page touches.

Airports named on this page:

Aircraft named on this page:

  • SU-BGM — full recovered movement record, every airport and every leg
  • SU-BND — full recovered movement record, every airport and every leg
  • SU-BTT — full recovered movement record, every airport and every leg

The two indexes: