← Table drill-downs
The 61 rows where no Kirk can be placed at all
Where this came from. On the Following overview, the table headed "Under that rule" — the table that re-counts the register after applying the site's ordinary standard of proof to the people column — carries a bottom line reading "Rows where no Kirk can be placed at all — 61." This page is that cell, opened. All 61 rows are below with every field the register holds on each of them, and the count here and the count printed on the overview agree exactly. The same table splits the register's 85 rows three ways: 18 involve Charlie Kirk, 6 are matched to a Turning Point event with neither Kirk at it, and these 61 are what is left.
What this slice is
A row is in this list when the register cannot place either Kirk at the claimed location on the
claimed date. That means three conditions holding at once: the compilers' sheet does not claim
Charlie Kirk on the row, the row is not matched to a sourced Turning Point event, and the sheet's
claim about Erika Kirk is not established by anything outside the sheet itself. In register terms
that is charlie_present = not_claimed, tpusa_event_present = unknown, and an Erika Location cell
that no independent record confirms. Reproduce the list from overlaps.csv by taking every row whose
Charlie Present column reads not_claimed and whose TPUSA Event Present column reads unknown.
Two things follow from that definition and both are worth stating before the tables. First, all 61
rows carry charlie_present = not_claimed and tpusa_event_present = unknown with no exceptions,
and all 61 carry erika_present = claimed. Second, and as a direct consequence, this list is the
same 61 rows as the Erika-alone slice. The two pages hold
identical rows because the rule and the claim land on the same set: every row that rests on Erika
Kirk alone is a row where nobody can be placed, since her presence is established on
zero rows anywhere in the register. The two pages
differ in what they ask of the list, not in what is in it.
At a glance
| Rows | 61 of the register's 85 |
| Distinct dates | 53 |
| Date range | 5 October 2022 to 13 September 2025, across the 56 rows that carry a date |
| Rows carrying no date at all | 5 — UNPUB-001 through UNPUB-005 |
| Aircraft | SU-BTT 42 · SU-BND 13 · "SU-BTT or SU-BND", source could not tell which, 5 · aircraft unknown 1 |
| Airports | KILG Wilmington 11 · KICT Wichita 10 · KOMA Omaha 10 · KPVU Provo 7 · KSTL St. Louis 5 · KLNK Lincoln 3 · KORD Chicago 2 · one row each at CYYR, KATL, KBGR, KBOS, KCPS, KJFK, KSMF, KSUS · no airport named 5 |
| States | NE 13 · DE 11 · KS 10 · MO 8 · UT 7 · IL 2 · one row each in CA, GA, MA, ME, NY · no state named 5 |
| By year | 2022: 9 · 2023: 17 · 2024: 16 · 2025: 14 · no date: 5 |
| ADS-B verdict | Not heard 29 · At the claimed airport, corroborated 12 · No archive coverage 10 · No date named 5 · Elsewhere, refuted 3 · No aircraft named 1 · Right area, wrong field 1 |
| Tracking-site audit verdict | Inaccurate 38 · Accurate 11 · Never published 5 · Partially accurate 4 · Not assessable, archive gap 2 · Not reached by the audit 1 |
| Who the sheet claims | Erika Kirk alone — 61 of 61. Charlie Kirk — 0. Turning Point event matched — 0. |
| Ground-position confirmations | 2 of 61 |
| Rows falling on a day this site independently sources a Kirk or TPUSA appearance | 5 of 61 |
| Charlie Kirk's presence established | 0 of 61 |
| Erika Kirk's presence established | 0 of 61 |
TABLE A — the following aircraft
| Row | Date claimed | Airport | City / State | Following aircraft | Type | ICAO hex | Arrived from | Departed to | Ground stay logged, arrived | Departed | Days | Transponder / ground flag | ADS-B verdict | Closest approach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OWENS-001 | 5 October 2022 | KJFK New York area (claimed) | New York, NY | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-002 | 20 October 2022 | KORD Chicago area (claimed) | Chicago, IL | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | New York via Paris | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-003 | 1 November 2022 | KBOS Boston area (claimed) | Boston, MA | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Chicago via Paris | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-004 | 13 November 2022 | KICT Wichita Dwight D. Eisenhower National | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | Wilmington DE 2022-11-17 | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-005 | 17 November 2022 | KILG Wilmington New Castle | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Wichita | Cairo (sheet said 11/17; audit says 11/20) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-043 | 25 November 2022 | KILG Wilmington (claimed) | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-044 | 5 December 2022 | KORD Chicago (claimed) | Chicago, IL | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-006 | 20 December 2022 | KSTL St. Louis Lambert / Downtown / Spirit (sheet says St. Louis) | St. Louis, MO | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | Bangor ME 2022-12-27 | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-007 | 27 December 2022 | KBGR Bangor International | Bangor, ME | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | St. Louis | Cairo (back 2023-01-03 per audit) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-045 | 12 January 2023 | KICT Wichita (claimed) | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-008 | 15 January 2023 | KATL Atlanta (claimed) | Atlanta, GA | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No archive coverage | — |
| OWENS-009 | 10 February 2023 | KILG Wilmington (claimed) | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Atlanta | Paris / Cairo | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-046 | 25 February 2023 | KSUS St. Louis Spirit of St. Louis (audit: one week at KSUS) | St. Louis, MO | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | Wilmington 3/2; Cairo 3/4 (audit) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 2.22 km |
| OWENS-047 | 15 March 2023 | KOMA Omaha (claimed) | Omaha, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-048 | 27 March 2023 | KILG Wilmington (claimed) | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Omaha (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-011 | 6 April 2023 | KILG Wilmington New Castle | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Missouri / St. Louis | Cairo (audit 4/6–4/8) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 1.63 km |
| OWENS-012 | 14 April 2023 | KICT Wichita Dwight D. Eisenhower National | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | Wilmington 2023-04-20 | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Right area, wrong field | 27.58 km |
| OWENS-013 | 20 April 2023 | KILG Wilmington New Castle | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Wichita | Giza / Cairo 2023-04-21 | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | on the ground, transmitting | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 0.56 km — on the ground |
| OWENS-014 | 3 May 2023 | KCPS St. Louis Downtown (sheet: Missouri test flight) | St. Louis, MO | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | not recorded | Cairo 2023-05-09 | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 2.07 km |
| OWENS-015 | 9 May 2023 | CYYR Goose Bay (via St. Louis → Cairo) | St. Louis then Goose Bay, MO | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | St. Louis | Goose Bay → Paris → Cairo | 9 May 2023 | 9 May 2023 | 0 | — | Elsewhere — refuted | 1062.56 km |
| OWENS-050 | 12 May 2023 | KSTL St. Louis (claimed) | St. Louis, MO | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Missouri (claimed) | Paris / Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Elsewhere — refuted | 7034.48 km |
| OWENS-051 | 8 June 2023 | KICT Wichita (claimed) | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-016 | 12 June 2023 | KPVU Provo Municipal (claimed) | Provo, UT | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Provo (claimed) | Paris / SLC (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-052 | 25 June 2023 | KILG Wilmington (claimed) | Wilmington, DE | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Wilmington (claimed) | Paris / Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-017 | 25 July 2023 | KLNK Lincoln (claimed) | Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-018 | 3 September 2023 | KILG Wilmington (claimed) | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Lincoln (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-019 | 10 January 2024 | KSMF Sacramento (claimed) | Sacramento, CA | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-021 | 14 February 2024 | KILG Wilmington New Castle | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Lincoln (audit) / Omaha (sheet) | Cairo (Wilmington 2 days per Ep 256, Cairo 16th) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 0.82 km |
| OWENS-053 | 10 March 2024 | KSTL St. Louis (claimed) | St. Louis, MO | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-022 | 18 March 2024 | KICT Wichita (claimed) | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-054 | 22 March 2024 | KICT Wichita (claimed) | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Wichita (claimed) | Wilmington / Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-055 | 15 April 2024 | KOMA Omaha (claimed) | Omaha, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-025 | 19 April 2024 | KPVU Provo Municipal via SLC | Provo, UT | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Cairo via Paris, Goose Bay, SLC (audit) | sat until 12 July (audit) | 19 April 2024 | 12 July 2024 | 84 | on the ground, transmitting | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 0.05 km — on the ground |
| OWENS-027 | 28 April 2024 | KILG Wilmington New Castle | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Provo | Cairo | 23 April 2024 | 28 April 2024 | 5 | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 1.56 km |
| OWENS-056 | 3 May 2024 | KSTL St. Louis (claimed test flight) | St. Louis, MO | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | not recorded | not recorded | 19 April 2024 | 12 July 2024 | 84 | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-057 | 10 May 2024 | KSTL St. Louis (claimed) | St. Louis, MO | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Missouri (claimed) | Paris / Cairo (claimed) | 19 April 2024 | 12 July 2024 | 84 | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-058 | 18 June 2024 | KLNK Lincoln (claimed) | Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Wilmington / Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-059 | 5 July 2024 | KICT Wichita (claimed) | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Wichita (claimed) | Wilmington / Paris (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-028 | 20 July 2024 | KOMA Omaha then Lincoln (claimed) | Omaha / Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | Wilmington / Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-060 | 25 July 2024 | KOMA Omaha then Lincoln (claimed) | Omaha / Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Wilmington / Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-029 | 17 August 2024 | KOMA Omaha then Lincoln (claimed) | Omaha / Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Wilmington / Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-030 | 8 December 2024 | KPVU Provo (claimed) | Provo, UT | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Provo (claimed) | Paris / SLC (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-031 | 12 January 2025 | KICT Wichita (claimed) | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-061 | 12 January 2025 | KICT Wichita (claimed) | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-032 | 17 January 2025 | KICT Wichita (claimed) | Wichita, KS | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-062 | 8 February 2025 | KOMA Omaha (claimed) | Omaha, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-064 | 19 April 2025 | KPVU Provo (claimed) | Provo, UT | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Provo (claimed) | Paris / SLC / Provo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-036 | 18 June 2025 | KOMA Omaha then Lincoln (claimed) | Omaha / Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Paris (claimed) | Wilmington / Cairo (claimed) | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | Elsewhere — refuted | 10139.55 km |
| OWENS-037 | 7 July 2025 | KPVU Provo (sheet said leaving; audit says still there) | Provo, UT | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Provo (actual) | nowhere — still in Provo | 23 May 2025 | 13 September 2025 | 113 | — | Not heard | — |
| OWENS-066 | 7 July 2025 | KPVU Provo (sheet said leaving) | Provo, UT | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Provo | nowhere — still in Provo | 23 May 2025 | 13 September 2025 | 113 | — | Not heard | — |
| EXTRA-004 | 11 July 2025 | KOMA Omaha (claimed by amplifier, not Owens sheet) | Omaha, NE | no tail named | not stated | — | not recorded | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No aircraft named | — |
| OWENS-038 | 20 July 2025 | KOMA Omaha Eppley then Lincoln | Omaha / Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris | Lincoln same day; Wilmington 2025-07-26; Cairo 2025-07-27 | 20 July 2025 | 20 July 2025 | 0 | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 1.33 km |
| OWENS-067 | 20 July 2025 | KLNK Lincoln (audit: terminated 20 Jul in Lincoln) | Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris via Omaha | Lincoln 20 Jul; return 26 Jul | 20 July 2025 | 26 July 2025 | 6 | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 7.20 km |
| OWENS-039 | 17 August 2025 | KOMA Omaha Eppley then Lincoln | Omaha / Lincoln, NE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X | 0101D3 | Cairo via Paris 16 Aug (audit) | Lincoln; Wilmington 8/23; Cairo 8/24 | 17 August 2025 | 17 August 2025 | 0 | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 0.50 km |
| SITE-005 | 10 September 2025 | KILG Wilmington Airport / New Castle Airport | Wilmington, DE | SU-BTT | Dassault Falcon 7X (hex 0101D3) | 0101D3 | Provo (KPVU), departed 07:14 am MT (time DISPUTED three ways - see SITE-006) | Cairo, 11 Sept - reported as 07:56 am and as ~11:56 UTC | 10 September 2025 | 11 September 2025 | 1 | on | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 1.75 km |
| OWENS-042 | 13 September 2025 | KPVU Provo Municipal | Provo, UT | SU-BND | Gulfstream (G550/G-IV, trackers disagree) | 01003E | Provo ramp since 2025-05-23 | Goose Bay → Paris 9/13; Paris → Cairo 9/15 | 23 May 2025 | 13 September 2025 | 113 | airborne position | At the claimed airport — corroborated | 0.62 km |
| UNPUB-001 | no date was ever published | — none named | none named | SU-BTT, SU-BND — source could not tell which | not stated | 0101D3; 01003E | not recorded | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No date named | — |
| UNPUB-002 | no date was ever published | — none named | none named | SU-BTT, SU-BND — source could not tell which | not stated | 0101D3; 01003E | not recorded | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No date named | — |
| UNPUB-003 | no date was ever published | — none named | none named | SU-BTT, SU-BND — source could not tell which | not stated | 0101D3; 01003E | not recorded | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No date named | — |
| UNPUB-004 | no date was ever published | — none named | none named | SU-BTT, SU-BND — source could not tell which | not stated | 0101D3; 01003E | not recorded | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No date named | — |
| UNPUB-005 | no date was ever published | — none named | none named | SU-BTT, SU-BND — source could not tell which | not stated | 0101D3; 01003E | not recorded | not recorded | no logged stay covers this date | — | — | — | No date named | — |
TABLE B — who they are claimed to have been following
| Row | Date claimed | Who the sheet claims was present | Erika location as the sheet gives it | Sourced Kirk / TPUSA appearance same day | Venue | Local time | Nearest airport to that venue | Kirk-side aircraft on record |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OWENS-001 | 5 October 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | New York | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in NY that week (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: TPUSA — Live Free Tour — University of Delaware (Candace Owens), Newark, DE (-2 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-002 | 20 October 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Illinois | Charlie — Live Free Tour — Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL | Florida State University | — | KTLH — Tallahassee International, 5 mi | none recorded |
| OWENS-003 | 1 November 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Massachusetts | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in MA (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-004 | 13 November 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Live Free UMKC Kansas City MO 2022-10-18 (25 days earlier, different state); Candace Owens Live Free UDelaware Newark DE 2022-10-03 (register: 25 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-005 | 17 November 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Candace Owens Live Free UDelaware Newark 2022-10-03 (45 days earlier) (register: 45 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-043 | 25 November 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie UNM Albuquerque 2022-11-30 (different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-044 | 5 December 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Illinois | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in IL Dec 2022 (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-006 | 20 December 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Missouri | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: AmericaFest 2022 Phoenix AZ 2022-12-17 to 2022-12-20 (different state, same days) (register: 0_different_state days away) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — AmericaFest 2022, Phoenix, AZ (-3 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-007 | 27 December 2022 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | never stated | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in Maine (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-045 | 12 January 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in KS Jan 2023 (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-008 | 15 January 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | never stated | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in GA that week (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-009 | 10 February 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie at ASU Tempe 2023-02-08 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Health, Wealth and Happiness — ASU Gammage, Tempe, AZ (-2 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-046 | 25 February 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Missouri | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie UIC Chicago 2023-03-09 (12 days later, different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-047 | 15 March 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Rutgers New Brunswick 2023-03-21 / Columbus 2023-03-22 (different states) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Live Free Tour — UC Davis, Davis, CA (-1 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-048 | 27 March 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware / Nebraska | Charlie — Live Free Tour — Texas Christian University, Fort Worth, TX | Texas Christian University | — | KFTW — Fort Worth Meacham International, 5 mi | none recorded |
| OWENS-011 | 6 April 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware / Missouri | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Jefferson City TPUSA Faith 2023-04-02 (4 days earlier, different state) (register: 4 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-012 | 14 April 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: TPUSA Faith Kingdom to the Capitol Topeka KS 2023-04-23 (register: 9 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-013 | 20 April 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Wichita / DE / potentially Giza | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Erika IG 2023-04-17 Odysea Aquarium with Charlie and GG (per @liztalny1023); Charlie Texas event 2023-04-22 per TPUSA IG; Topeka Faith 2023-04-23 (register: 3 days away) · Nearest in the events catalog: TPUSA — TPUSA Faith Kingdom to the Capitol — Topeka, Topeka, KS (+3 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-014 | 3 May 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Missouri | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Nashville Pastors Summit May 2023 (month only, different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-015 | 9 May 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Missouri / Cairo | None same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days. | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-050 | 12 May 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Missouri / Cairo | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in MO mid-May 2023 (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-051 | 8 June 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: YWLS Grapevine TX 2023-06-09 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Young Women's Leadership Summit 2023, Grapevine, TX (+1 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-016 | 12 June 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Utah | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none sourced in UT in June 2023; Utah record on this site begins April 2024 (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Young Women's Leadership Summit 2023, Grapevine, TX (-3 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-052 | 25 June 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in DE June 2023 (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-017 | 25 July 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie speaks Lincoln NE 2023-08-25 (31 days later; audit still places aircraft in Egypt that day too) (register: 31 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-018 | 3 September 2023 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware / Nebraska | None same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days. | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-019 | 10 January 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | California | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Restoring National Confidence Las Vegas 2024-01-29 to 2024-02-04 (different state, 19 days later) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-021 | 14 February 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware / Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Lincoln chapter 2024-02-11 (3 days earlier) (register: 3 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-053 | 10 March 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Missouri | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Cal Poly SLO 2024-03-07 / Fullerton 2024-03-14 (California) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Prove Me Wrong table — Cal Poly SLO, San Luis Obispo, CA (-3 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-022 | 18 March 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas | Charlie — Live Free / Prove Me Wrong — San Diego State University, San Diego, CA | San Diego State University | — | KSAN — San Diego International, 4 mi | none recorded |
| OWENS-054 | 22 March 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas / Delaware | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie UNLV 2024-03-21 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Campus event — UNLV, Las Vegas, NV (-1 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-055 | 15 April 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Omaha Lord of Hosts 2024-04-09 (6 days earlier) — a real Charlie appearance with NO aircraft in Nebraska (register: 6 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-025 | 19 April 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Utah | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Prove Me Wrong University of Utah 2024-04-23 (4 days later) (register: 4 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-027 | 28 April 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Delaware / Utah | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: U of Utah 2024-04-23 (5 days earlier) (register: 5 days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-056 | 3 May 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Missouri | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Seattle 2024-05-07 (different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-057 | 10 May 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Missouri | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in MO May 2024 (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Prove Me Wrong tabling — UNLV, Las Vegas, NV (-2 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-058 | 18 June 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: People's Convention Detroit 2024-06-14 (different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-059 | 5 July 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas / Delaware | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in KS July 2024 (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-028 | 20 July 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in NE July 2024 (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-060 | 25 July 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie West Palm Beach 2024-07-24 and 2024-07-26 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Turning Point Academy Educators' Summit 2024, West Palm Beach, FL (-1 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-029 | 17 August 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in NE Aug 2024 (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-030 | 8 December 2024 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Utah | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: AmericaFest 2024 Phoenix 2024-12-19 to 2024-12-24 (different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-031 | 12 January 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Washington DC 2025-01-19 (different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-061 | 12 January 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas | None same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days. | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-032 | 17 January 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Kansas | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: none in KS Jan 2025 (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Turning Point's Inaugural Eve Ball, Washington, DC (+2 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-062 | 8 February 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Phoenix 2025-02-18 (different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-064 | 19 April 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Utah | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Laramie 2025-04-24 (different state). SU-BGM WAS at Provo 2025-04-16 — different tail, not in the 73-tally. (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — American Comeback Tour — Texas A&M, College Station, TX (+3 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-036 | 18 June 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: YWLS Grapevine TX 2025-06-13 to 2025-06-15 (the only well-dated joint Charlie-and-Erika appearance before Sept 10 — and no aircraft in Texas) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-037 | 7 July 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Utah | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie SAS Tampa 2025-07-11 (different state) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Chapter Leadership Summit 2025, Tampa, FL (+2 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-066 | 7 July 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Utah | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: SAS Tampa 2025-07-11 (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Chapter Leadership Summit 2025, Tampa, FL (+2 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| EXTRA-004 | 11 July 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | never stated | Charlie — TPUSA Student Action Summit 2025, Tampa, FL | Tampa Convention Center, 333 S Franklin St, Tampa, FL | — | KTPA — Tampa International, 6 mi | none recorded |
| OWENS-038 | 20 July 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie SAS Tampa FL 2025-07-11 to 2025-07-13 (9 days earlier, different state). Charlie Omaha 2024-04-09 / 2024-10-22 (15+ months earlier). (register: 9_different_state days away) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-067 | 20 July 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: SAS Tampa 2025-07-11 (9 days earlier, different state) (register, gap not stated) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| OWENS-039 | 17 August 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Nebraska | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: Charlie Win the Storm Dallas 2025-08-20 to 2025-08-22 and North Myrtle Beach 2025-08-21 (different states, during the Lincoln dwell) (register, gap not stated) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — Win the Storm, Dallas, TX (+3 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| SITE-005 | 10 September 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | 'Nebraska/Delaware' (spreadsheet) vs ARIZONA (Erika Kirk's own account) | Charlie — The American Comeback Tour — UVU (first stop of the fall tour), Orem, UT | Utah Valley University, Sorensen Center courtyard | event ~10:00 MDT announced; shot at 12:23:30 PM MDT | KPVU — Provo Municipal Airport, 5 mi | none recorded |
| OWENS-042 | 13 September 2025 | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | Utah | None same-day. Register's nearest sourced appearance: UVU 2025-09-10 (3 days earlier) (register: 3 days away) · Nearest in the events catalog: Charlie — The American Comeback Tour — UVU (first stop of the fall tour), Orem, UT (-3 days) | — | — | — | none recorded |
| UNPUB-001 | no date was ever published | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | never stated | None same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days. | — | — | — | none recorded |
| UNPUB-002 | no date was ever published | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | never stated | None same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days. | — | — | — | none recorded |
| UNPUB-003 | no date was ever published | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | never stated | None same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days. | — | — | — | none recorded |
| UNPUB-004 | no date was ever published | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | never stated | None same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days. | — | — | — | none recorded |
| UNPUB-005 | no date was ever published | Charlie: not claimed · Erika: claimed | never stated | None same-day. Neither this register's own nearest-event column nor a date join against the sourced speaking-events catalog finds a Kirk or TPUSA appearance within three days. | — | — | — | none recorded |
TABLE C — sourcing and both verdicts
| Row | Sheet index | Audit verdict (tracking-site pass) | ADS-B verdict (position data) | What the position data says | Source of the claim | Source post | Full row page |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
OWENS-001 | 1 | Inaccurate | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit screenshots; Erika Location column reads New York on the visible extract | post | open |
OWENS-002 | 2 | Inaccurate | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-003 | 3 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsbexchange-samples served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-004 | 4 | Accurate | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE); Owens Ep 268 Wilmington recap | post | open |
OWENS-005 | 5 | Inaccurate | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit; Owens Ep 268 | post | open |
OWENS-043 | 43 | Not assessable — archive gap | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (archive gap) | post | open |
OWENS-044 | 44 | Not assessable — archive gap | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (archive gap) | post | open |
OWENS-006 | 6 | Accurate | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE) | post | open |
OWENS-007 | 7 | Accurate | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE) | post | open |
OWENS-045 | 45 | Inaccurate | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-008 | 8 | Inaccurate | No archive coverage | SAYS NOTHING EITHER WAY. Neither free archive holds this date for any airframe we probed, so this is an archive limit and not suppression. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-009 | 9 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN ABSENCE… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-046 | 46 | Partially accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 2.2 km from KSUS at -113 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. This trace holds no on-ground positions at all, which is ordinary:… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (partial) | post | open |
OWENS-047 | 47 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-048 | 48 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-011 | 11 | Accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 1.6 km from KILG at -105 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. This trace holds no on-ground positions at all, which is ordinary:… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE 4/6–4/8) | post | open |
OWENS-012 | 12 | Accurate | Right area, wrong field | RIGHT AREA, WRONG FIELD. Closest recovered position is 28 km from KICT - inside the source sheet's own 50-100 mile tolerance, outside a same-airport test. Neither confirmed nor refuted. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE 4/14); Owens Ep 256 INFILTRATION (Sacramento 4/13 then Cairo-to-Kansas) | post | open |
OWENS-013 | 13 | Accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED, AND ON THE GROUND. A trace we pulled and kept puts this airframe on the ground 0.6 km from KILG on the claimed date. It places NOBODY aboard. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE — second leg of ref 12); @liztalny1023 19 Nov 2025 on the Giza cell | post | open |
OWENS-014 | 14 | Accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 2.1 km from KCPS at 1,137 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. This trace holds no on-ground positions at all, which is ordinary:… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE that it flew in St. Louis; data does not say test flight) | post | open |
OWENS-015 | 15 | Accurate | Elsewhere — refuted | REFUTED. The airframe was tracked that day and its closest recovered position is 1,063 km from CYYR. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE overall) | post | open |
OWENS-050 | 50 | Inaccurate | Elsewhere — refuted | REFUTED. The airframe was tracked that day and its closest recovered position is 7,034 km from KSTL. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-051 | 51 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-016 | 16 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-052 | 52 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-017 | 17 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-018 | 18 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-019 | 19 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit; @liztalny1023 19 Nov 2025 quoting the California cell | post | open |
OWENS-021 | 21 | Inaccurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 0.8 km from KILG at -180 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. This trace holds no on-ground positions at all, which is ordinary:… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (INACCURATE origin city); Owens Ep 256 | post | open |
OWENS-053 | 53 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-022 | 22 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-054 | 54 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-055 | 55 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-025 | 25 | Inaccurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED, AND ON THE GROUND. A trace we pulled and kept puts this airframe on the ground 0.1 km from KPVU on the claimed date. It places NOBODY aboard. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (route wrong); Owens Ep 256 | post | open |
OWENS-027 | 27 | Accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 1.6 km from KILG at -80 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. The only on-ground positions in this trace are at KPVU (Provo… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE); Owens Ep 256 | post | open |
OWENS-056 | 56 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-057 | 57 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-058 | 58 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-059 | 59 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-028 | 28 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-060 | 60 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-029 | 29 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-030 | 30 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-031 | 31 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-061 | 61 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-032 | 32 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-062 | 62 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-064 | 64 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-036 | 36 | Inaccurate | Elsewhere — refuted | REFUTED. The airframe was tracked that day and its closest recovered position is 10,140 km from KOMA. | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-037 | 37 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
OWENS-066 | 66 | Inaccurate | Not heard | SAYS ALMOST NOTHING. adsb-lol/airplanes-live served other airframes that day but holds no trace for this one. Parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from here. AN… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit | post | open |
EXTRA-004 | — | Not reached by the audit | No aircraft named | The claim names no tail number, so there is no airframe to look up. Untestable as published. | @bfr1273 19 Aug 2026 citing a Stew Peters X post of 5 Aug 2026 and a guest | post | open |
OWENS-038 | 38 | Partially accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 1.3 km from KOMA at 591 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. The only on-ground positions in this trace are at LFPB (Paris-Le… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (partial); Candace first posts; flights.csv | post | open |
OWENS-067 | 67 | Accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 7.2 km from KLNK at 881 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. The only on-ground positions in this trace are at LFPB (Paris-Le… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (accurate-ish) | post | open |
OWENS-039 | 39 | Partially accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 0.5 km from KOMA at 391 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. This trace holds no on-ground positions at all, which is ordinary:… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (partial); flights.csv | post | open |
SITE-005 | — | Partially accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 1.7 km from KILG at -105 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. The only on-ground positions in this trace are at KPVU (Provo… | Compilation spreadsheet circulated by trackers; alternate tracker read @troofevades (takeoff ~13:14 UTC, landing ~16:52 UTC); audit index 41 (flight confirmed, origin corrected from… | — | open |
OWENS-042 | 42 | Accurate | At the claimed airport — corroborated | CORROBORATED IN THE AIR, NOT ON THE GROUND. Closest recovered position is 0.6 km from KPVU at 3 ft above the field - an arrival, a departure or a low pass. This trace holds no on-ground positions at all, which is ordinary:… | Owens sheet via Kanekoa audit (ACCURATE) | post | open |
UNPUB-001 | — | Never published | No date named | The claim carries no date, so no archive can be asked about it. Untestable as published. | Candace Owens, Operation Mocking-Plane, 17 Nov 2025: '68 overlaps. I have since been able to add now 73 times that this overlapped.' | post | open |
UNPUB-002 | — | Never published | No date named | The claim carries no date, so no archive can be asked about it. Untestable as published. | Candace Owens, Operation Mocking-Plane, 17 Nov 2025: '68 overlaps. I have since been able to add now 73 times that this overlapped.' | post | open |
UNPUB-003 | — | Never published | No date named | The claim carries no date, so no archive can be asked about it. Untestable as published. | Candace Owens, Operation Mocking-Plane, 17 Nov 2025: '68 overlaps. I have since been able to add now 73 times that this overlapped.' | post | open |
UNPUB-004 | — | Never published | No date named | The claim carries no date, so no archive can be asked about it. Untestable as published. | Candace Owens, Operation Mocking-Plane, 17 Nov 2025: '68 overlaps. I have since been able to add now 73 times that this overlapped.' | post | open |
UNPUB-005 | — | Never published | No date named | The claim carries no date, so no archive can be asked about it. Untestable as published. | Candace Owens, Operation Mocking-Plane, 17 Nov 2025: '68 overlaps. I have since been able to add now 73 times that this overlapped.' | post | open |
What the specifics show
This is the largest block in the register and it is the block with the least on the people side.
Sixty-one of eighty-five rows — a little over seven in ten — reach the end of the placement test with
nobody in them. Not one of the 61 claims Charlie Kirk. Not one is matched to a sourced Turning Point
event. All 61 rest on the sheet's Erika Location column, and that column, read across this slice,
holds a bare US state on most of its rows — Nebraska on 12, Kansas on 8, Utah on 7, Missouri on 6,
Delaware on 4 — reads UNKNOWN on 8, and names two places at once on rows such as OWENS-018, where
it says "Delaware / Nebraska". A state is not a location and none of these entries is an itinerary.
The aircraft side of the same 61 rows is a different quality of record, and it survives. Position
data recovered by this investigation puts the named airframe at the named field on 12 of them.
The two strongest are ground-flag records rather than airborne passes: OWENS-013, SU-BTT
transmitting from the ground 0.56 km from Wilmington New Castle on 20 April 2023, and
OWENS-025, SU-BND on the ground 0.05 km from Provo on 19 April 2024. The tightest airborne
corroborations are OWENS-039 at 0.50 km from Omaha on 17 August 2025, OWENS-042 at 0.62 km
from Provo on 13 September 2025, and OWENS-021 at 0.82 km from Wilmington on 14 February 2024.
Those rows establish that an Egyptian-registered jet was where the sheet said it was. They establish
nothing at all about who was inside it, and that is precisely why these rows are on this page rather
than on the Charlie page.
Three rows are refuted outright by the same data, and the misses are not marginal. On OWENS-015
(9 May 2023, Goose Bay) the closest recovered position is 1,063 km from the claimed field; on
OWENS-050 (12 May 2023, St. Louis) it is 7,034 km; on OWENS-036 (18 June 2025, Omaha) it is
10,140 km. One further row, OWENS-012 (14 April 2023, Wichita), lands 28 km out — inside
the sheet's own stated 50-to-100-mile tolerance, outside a same-airport test, and therefore recorded
as neither confirmed nor refuted.
Five rows fall on a day this site can independently source a Kirk or TPUSA appearance, and all five
point away from the claim. On OWENS-002 (20 October 2022) the jet is claimed at Chicago while the
sourced Charlie Kirk appearance is at Florida State in Tallahassee. On OWENS-048 (27 March 2023) it
is Wilmington against Texas Christian in Fort Worth. On OWENS-022 (18 March 2024), Wichita against
San Diego State. On EXTRA-004 (11 July 2025), Omaha against the Student Action Summit in Tampa. On
SITE-005 (10 September 2025), Wilmington against Utah Valley University in Orem. In every one of
the five the aircraft and the one documented person are in different states.
Where the list is weakest is where it is largest. Twenty-nine rows come back Not heard and a further ten fall in windows no free archive reaches — thirty-nine of the sixty-one, nearly two-thirds, on which the archives say nothing either way. Five rows carry no date at all, so no archive can be asked about them. The tracking-site audit, working the same claims against paid flight-history archives, called 38 of the 61 inaccurate against 11 accurate.
The two verdict passes disagree on three rows, and the disagreement is published rather than
resolved. OWENS-021 (14 February 2024, Wilmington, 0.82 km) and OWENS-025 (19 April 2024,
Provo, 0.05 km with the ground flag set) were called inaccurate by the audit and are
corroborated by recovered position data. OWENS-015 (9 May 2023, Goose Bay) runs the other way:
the audit called it accurate and the position data puts the airframe 1,063 km away. The two
methods used different evidence — one re-read tracking-site pages, the other measured stored position
traces — and where they conflict, both results stay on the row.
What this list cannot tell you
- A trace locates an aircraft. It never places a person aboard. The 12 corroborations and the 2 ground-flag records on this page establish airframe positions and nothing more. No passenger, named or otherwise, is placed in any cabin by anything here.
- Erika Kirk's presence is established on zero of these 61 rows. Her flight logs are reported erased, and no dated itinerary for her has been published by the compilers, by Turning Point USA, or by anyone else. Every row on this page rests on a spreadsheet cell the compilers filled in, not on a record placing her anywhere.
- Charlie Kirk's presence is established on zero of these 61 rows too, because the sheet never claims him on any of them. The 18 rows that do involve him are a separate slice and are not counted here.
- An absence in an archive is not an absence in the world, and it is never a deletion. The 29 Not heard rows mean volunteer archives served other airframes that day and hold no trace for this one; parked with the transponder off, outside receiver coverage, and a wrong claimed date all look identical from outside. The 10 No archive coverage rows mean no free archive reaches that date for any airframe probed, control aircraft included. Both are limits of the archives. Neither is suppression and neither is evidence of absence.
- "No Kirk can be placed" is a statement about the record, not about the world. It does not say neither Kirk was there. It says nothing outside the compilers' own spreadsheet puts either of them there, and this site's ordinary standard is that an unestablished claim is not treated as established. Every row is published in full so a reader can apply a different standard and see exactly what changes.
- A wrong spreadsheet row is an error, not misconduct. Nothing on this page asserts that any living person committed any crime. The sheet is the compilers'; the audit verdicts are the auditor's; the ADS-B verdicts are this investigation's, measured off raw traces. The ordinary explanations the register carries alongside these claims — Duncan Aviation's Egyptian Air Force maintenance account, post-maintenance test flights, transatlantic customs and fuel stops — are printed on the rows themselves.
- On the count. The overview prints 61 rows across 53 distinct dates for this cell and the data behind this page returns the same 61 and the same 53, so there is nothing to reconcile. Note separately that the tracking-site audit quoted elsewhere on the overview worked from a 78-row version of the register while this register holds 85; where an audit percentage and a register count appear to disagree, that is usually why.
Related
- The Following overview — the page whose table cell this is
- The overlap index — one page per claimed overlap
- The speaking-events catalog — the sourced Kirk and TPUSA appearances these rows are tested against
- The rows where Erika Kirk's presence is actually established — there are none, which is why these 61 land here
- The 61 rows resting on Erika Kirk alone — the identical row set, asked a different question
- Every row that involves Charlie Kirk at all — the 18 rows this slice excludes
- The six rows matched to a Turning Point event with neither Kirk — the other block excluded from this one
- Every claimed overlap, all 85 rows — 18 + 6 + 61
- Erika Kirk's flight logs, reported erased
- Aircraft pages: SU-BTT — 42 of these rows · SU-BND — 13 of these rows
Flight-record pages for what is on this page
This investigation keeps one page per airport and one page per recorded ground contact, built directly from the recovered ADS-B traces. These are the ones this page touches.
Ground contacts near a sourced Charlie / Erika / TPUSA event:
| Date (UTC) | Aircraft | Airport | City, State | Whose event | When |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-04-23 | N888KG | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2024-04-23 | SU-BTT | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2025-07-13 | N582MM | KTPA | Tampa, FL | Charlie | Day after |
| 2025-09-10 | N102DZ | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2025-09-10 | N40JD | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2025-09-10 | N560TW | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2025-09-10 | N59906 | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2025-09-10 | N872RA | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2025-09-10 | N888KG | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2025-09-10 | SU-BND | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
| 2025-09-10 | SU-BTT | KPVU | Provo, UT | Charlie | Same day |
Airports named on this page:
- KPVU — Provo Municipal Airport, Provo, UT — 135 recorded ground visits, 13 tracked aircraft
- KILG — Wilmington Airport / New Castle Airport, Wilmington, DE — 28 recorded ground visits, 3 tracked aircraft
- LFPB — Paris-Le Bourget Airport, Le Bourget, France — 14 recorded ground visits, 4 tracked aircraft
- KORD — Chicago O'Hare International Airport, Chicago, IL — 3 recorded ground visits, 2 tracked aircraft
- KBGR — Bangor International Airport, Bangor, ME — 2 recorded ground visits, 1 tracked aircraft
- KLNK — Lincoln Airport, Lincoln, NE — 2 recorded ground visits, 2 tracked aircraft
- KICT — Wichita Dwight D. Eisenhower National Airport, Wichita, KS — 1 recorded ground visit, 1 tracked aircraft
- KSAN — San Diego International, San Diego, CA — 44 recorded ground visits, 5 tracked aircraft
- KFTW — Fort Worth Meacham International, Fort Worth, TX — 7 recorded ground visits, 4 tracked aircraft
- KTPA — Tampa International, Tampa, FL — 7 recorded ground visits, 2 tracked aircraft
- KSMF — Sacramento International Airport, Sacramento, CA — 5 recorded ground visits, 2 tracked aircraft
- KATL — Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport, Atlanta, GA — 4 recorded ground visits, 2 tracked aircraft
- KBOS — Boston Logan International Airport, Boston, MA — 4 recorded ground visits, 2 tracked aircraft
- KSTL — Lambert-St. Louis International Airport, St. Louis, MO — 2 recorded ground visits, 1 tracked aircraft
Aircraft named on this page:
- SU-BGM — full recovered movement record, every airport and every leg
- SU-BND — full recovered movement record, every airport and every leg
- SU-BTT — full recovered movement record, every airport and every leg
The two indexes:
- Every airport in this investigation — 290 fields, each with its complete recovered ground-visit and flight-leg record
- Every interesting date, all aircraft — 147 ground contacts near a sourced event, across 110 pages
- Investigating Deleted Flights — how the data was recovered, how much of it we hold, and where it is still missing