Booking Sheet Arrest Time Contradicts the Affidavit (Claims)
:::caution Attributed claims only A single custody event routinely generates several different official timestamps, and a discrepancy between two of them is not by itself evidence of misconduct. What follows are reported claims from citizen researchers about documents they say they have reviewed. No officer named or implied here has been charged with or found to have committed any wrongdoing. Tyler Robinson is charged, not convicted. :::
Claim snapshot
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| The claim | Two official records reportedly give arrest times six hours apart, and the earlier one predates the affidavit's own arrival time |
| Raised by | Independent researchers; @Partisangirl (Syrian Girl / Dr. Maram Susli) |
| First surfaced | Undated in source |
| Rests on | Document — booking paperwork and a submission record, as described by researchers |
| Evidence rating | MODERATE |
What is alleged
Researchers circulating images of Robinson's intake paperwork say two documents in the same file give two different arrest times. An "Inmate Booking Sheet and PC Statement" reportedly attributed to the Utah County Sheriff's Office lists the arrest at 10:00pm on September 11, 2025. A separate submission record reportedly lists "Arrest Date/Time: 09/12/2025 04:00", with "Probable Cause Entered: 09/12/2025 07:18", Probable Cause ID 189904, booking agency Utah County Sheriff Office, agency inmate ID 460956, and the submitting officer identified as UTBDAVIS — Brian Davis, described on the form as a sworn officer with the Attorney General's office.
The sharper problem researchers point to is internal. The government's own probable-cause narrative reportedly states that "Tyler Robinson arrived at the Washington County Sheriff's Office accompanied by his parents at approximately 2226 hours" — 10:26pm. If the booking sheet's arrest time of 10:00pm is accurate, then on the face of the two documents Robinson was arrested twenty-six minutes before he arrived at the building where the arrest is said to have occurred. Researchers argue the two figures cannot both describe the same event, and that the 4:00am figure looks less like a moment of detention than like the moment the paperwork caught up to a custody that had already been underway for hours.
Those raising it connect the gap to the broader dispute over when Robinson actually came in — see the Miranda timing question — and note that a roughly 260-mile transport between Washington County and Utah County takes three to four hours each way, which they say makes some of the published sequence physically difficult.
The ordinary explanation
Booking paperwork is not a single clock. One custody event ordinarily generates several distinct, legitimately different timestamps: the time a person was first detained, the time a sworn officer formally effected the arrest, the time a probable-cause statement was drafted and entered, and the time the receiving jail completed booking. These can differ by hours in an entirely routine case, and they differ more — not less — when two agencies at opposite ends of a state are involved and a long interagency transport sits between the first contact and the final booking. A 04:00 entry recorded by a Utah County officer is exactly what you would expect if that officer completed the formal arrest and booking sequence after driving a suspect several hours north. The 07:18 probable-cause entry then follows naturally as the time the sworn statement was filed.
The apparent 10:00pm-before-10:26pm inversion is also the kind of thing clerical convention produces constantly. Different agencies populate the "arrest" field differently — some enter the time of the originating event, some the time of first contact, some a rounded estimate — and a hand-entered round number like "10:00pm" has the texture of an approximation rather than a logged observation. An affidavit's "approximately 2226 hours" is itself explicitly approximate. Two approximations from two agencies landing half an hour apart is unremarkable, and reading a conspiracy into a rounded field is a heavy load for that field to bear.
What would settle it
- Obtain the complete, unredacted Inmate Booking Sheet and PC Statement and the corresponding submission record together, so both timestamps can be read in context rather than from circulated crops.
- Depose or obtain a written statement from Officer Brian Davis on what the 04:00 arrest entry was intended to record and when he physically took custody.
- Request the Utah County Sheriff's Office records-management data dictionary — the written convention defining what its "Arrest Date/Time" field means — which would resolve whether the two entries are contradictory or simply measuring different things.
- Pull dispatch/CAD logs and transport records for the Washington-to-Utah County trip, which would independently fix the departure and arrival times.
Interesting In This Area
- A 6:25pm Miranda warning would predate the tip call by ninety minutes.
- No bodycam and purged CCTV leaves the arrival time without a video anchor.
- Robinson reportedly did not surrender voluntarily, per Candace Owens.
- Closed hearings mean no transcript settles the custody sequence publicly.
Interesting In Other Areas
- The arrest and booking timeline lays every timestamp side by side.
- The probable-cause affidavit is the document the booking sheet is measured against.
- Surrender collects what the state says happened that evening.
- September 11 custody reconstructs the same hours from the aftermath side.
Images
Videos
Footage related to this page. Each card opens that clip's own page, with the video, the full write-up, and its source.
Other Pages In This Section
No Autopsy and the Death-Certificate Questions (Claims)
The claim is that no autopsy was performed. Utah seals medical examiner records during an active capital case, so "no public report" and "no report" are being treated as the same statement when they are not. A question with a published answer the questioner did not look for.
Read this
The Unknown Woman Who Reportedly Signed the Medical Examiner Report (Claims)
An anonymous direct message says Kirk's autopsy was signed by a young woman the medical examiner had never met. No name, no document, no second witness. It is recorded here only so it can be checked or retired rather than circulating forever.
Read this
Charred Material and Fragments in the SUV (Claims)
A broadcast screenshot shows a pale fragment whose edges look scorched, and one question: why is there burned material in the SUV? Nothing has been recovered, identified or lab-tested. What is being analyzed is a photograph of a photograph.
Read thisSuspicious Hospital, Autopsy and Medical
Ten things citizen investigators flag about the hospital, the transport, the medical examiner and the autopsy. Several of these items are contradicted by the investigation file's own text, and these pages say so rather than tidying it away.
Read thisElsewhere In The Investigation
Arrest, Booking & Probable Cause Affidavit Timeline
Four documents describe the same arrest and they do not agree on when it happened. The booking sheet says 10:00 PM on the 11th; the police system record says 04:00 on the 12th.
Read this
Probable Cause Affidavit (Police Booking)
The police-side booking document that established the legal basis for the detention — and the first place the government commits to its theory of how Charlie Kirk was killed. The full PDF is on the page.
Read thisTyler Robinson Surrender — September 11
The reported September 11 surrender at the Washington County Sheriff's Office — the Brooksby timeline, the 6:25 PM Miranda, the missing bodycam, the 33-hour manhunt framing. Everything the surrender video would settle.
Read thisSept 11 Surrender and Custody Timeline
Miranda at 6:25 PM, a sheriff's first identification call at 8:02 PM, Discord messages at 7:57 PM. The order of those three timestamps is the entire dispute, and no public record has reconciled them.
Read thisSources
- @Partisangirl (Dr. Maram Susli): https://x.com/Partisangirl/status/2068463186668605858
- Investigation file notes describing the "Inmate Booking Sheet and PC Statement" and the submission record fields (Probable Cause ID 189904; OTN 70090584)
This website's author is @HolonCitizen on X and YouTube/@HolonCitizen. Follow me there.
Interesting
- A 112-page records release reportedly includes a redacted message request directed to Charlie Kirk.
- A friction checklist logs a private White House back-channel on Iran.
- Analysts report foreign networks amplifying rival Kirk narratives within days.