The Messages Attributed to Tyler Robinson
The case against Tyler Robinson rests heavily on messages. They did not all arrive the same way, they were not all stored in the same place, and they did not all reach investigators through the same route. This page separates them by where each one lived before anyone in law enforcement saw it, because that storage question is what determines how each set can be authenticated. Open a kind below for the record, the storage location, and the disputes attached to it. None of these messages establishes how Charlie Kirk was killed — that question turns on the physical evidence, where the majority citizen finding points to an explosive device rather than the government's rifle.
The State Numbered Them The Same Way
This split is not a framing invented here. The State's memorandum supporting bindover — a 28-page filing published July 29, 2026 by attorney @aburkhartlaw — files the message material as a single numbered series:
| Exhibit | What it is |
|---|---|
| State's Ex. 16 | Transcript of the Lance Twiggs police interview |
| State's Ex. 16.1 | The Robinson–Twiggs text messages (17+ pages) |
| State's Ex. 16.2 | The Discord messages (2 pages) |
| State's Ex. 16.3 | The handwritten note |
| State's Ex. 16.4 | Cited alongside the surveillance screen captures |
Steam material appears nowhere in the series, which is the clearest available confirmation that it is not part of the state's case.
Read the full memorandum (PDF, 28 pages)
Where Each Set Was Stored
Four storage locations, four different evidentiary problems.
Discord — a third-party server. The alleged confession posts lived on Discord's infrastructure, in servers reported under usernames including Craftopia, Gamin and The Corruption. Records of that kind are obtained by warrant served on the company. The Utah State Bureau of Investigation reportedly did serve such a warrant. What the public has been shown, however, is photographs and screenshots rather than a native export, and the earliest capture described in the charging affidavit is a photograph taken of a roommate's own phone screen while he scrolled through the messages.
Text messages — a second person's phone. The Robinson-Twiggs exchanges were not recovered from a device attributed to Robinson. They were extracted from the phone belonging to Lance Twiggs, using Cellebrite forensic tooling, and Agent Davis testified about that extraction in open court. This is the one message set with a described forensic chain and courtroom testimony behind it.
Paper — under a keyboard in an apartment. The handwritten note had no server, no timestamp and no metadata. According to the charging materials it was left under a keyboard at the apartment Robinson shared with Twiggs. Its date and authorship can only be established by handwriting analysis, physical examination and the surrounding testimony — which is precisely why researchers have pressed on it.
Steam — a public gaming profile. Archived Steam material (the "craftin247" and "milk" profiles, captions and comments) was scraped from publicly visible pages by citizen researchers before those pages were reportedly scrubbed. It is not confession material and is not part of the state's core case; it is background circulated online as character evidence, and it should be read that way.
Why The Storage Question Matters
Every dispute on these pages traces back to storage. The custody-timing objection — that a Discord post timestamped after Robinson was already Mirandized could not have been typed by him — only works because Discord posts carry server-side timestamps. The note has no such problem and no such check. The texts sit in between: a real forensic extraction, but of somebody else's device.
There is also a filing that cuts across all of it. A state filing opposing a defense continuance reportedly stated that the state did not intend to offer evidence obtained through forensic extractions of the electronics seized in the case. If that is accurate, the strongest authentication path for the digital material may not be the path the prosecution actually walks at hearing, even while public reporting leans on that material heavily. Readers should verify against the current docket rather than take that summary as settled.
How To Read These Pages
Nothing here alleges that any message was fabricated. No examiner and no court has found the note or the messages to be anything other than what the state says they are, and the defense — which holds the underlying data — has not publicly claimed forgery. What this section documents is that authentication and timing remain open questions on the Discord set, that the text set has the clearest chain, and that the note has the least testable form of all. Those are three different evidentiary positions and they should not be collapsed into one.
For the fuller authentication and custody-timing argument as it developed, see the original Discord Messages page, which remains the long-form treatment of that dispute.
Interesting In This Area
- The texts came off a roommate's phone, not the accused's device.
- The note has no timestamp, because paper does not record when it was written.
- Discord posts are two pages of Exhibit 16.2, excerpted rather than produced.
- Steam material is absent from the exhibit series entirely.
Interesting In Other Areas
- Cellebrite extracted the phone; an agent described one extraction in court.
- Lance Twiggs owned the handset and is charged with nothing.
- Citizen analysis says a device at the microphone, not a roof round.
- Acoustic analysis reportedly separates two sounds at two distances.
Other Pages In This Section
Text Messages — Recovered From Lance Twiggs' Phone
The message set with the clearest forensic chain — and the chain runs through the roommate's phone, not through any device attributed to the accused. Filed as State's Exhibit 16.1 and cited page by page to at least seventeen.
Read this
Discord Messages — Stored on a Third-Party Server
What the alleged confession actually says, which servers held it, and how it reached investigators. State's Exhibit 16.2 in the bindover memorandum — excerpted, never produced in full.
Read thisThe Handwritten Note — Stored Under a Keyboard
The one message in this case stored under a keyboard rather than on a server: no timestamp, no account, no metadata to authenticate or to dispute. It is State's Exhibit 16.3, and the memorandum's lead identity quotation is drawn from it.
Read thisSteam Profile and Comments — Stored on a Public Gaming Platform
An eleven-year gaming profile scraped from public pages and read afterwards as red flags in plain sight. Two facts survive that hindsight problem: a documented rename from craftin247 to milk, and the reported scrubbing of pages anyone could once load.
Read thisElsewhere In The Investigation
Prosecutors disclaimed forensic extractions; an agent then described performing exactly one, on a Cellebrite tool. The testimony and the disclaimer are quoted side by side.
Read this
Tyler Robinson's partner and roommate, charged with nothing, pulled into the record by the state's own investigation. Her messages and her phone became evidence in a case where she is not a defendant.
Read this
Explosive in Mic Likely Killed Charlie
The finding citizen investigators on X have converged on: a device at the microphone, not a round from a roof. It is the single largest divergence between the public record and the government's account.
Read this
Broadcast audio at 48 kHz reportedly separates a distant muzzle blast from a louder event about 46 meters away at the stage. Two sounds, two distances — and the fatal mechanism may not be the rooftop rifle.
Read thisThis website's author is @HolonCitizen on X and YouTube/@HolonCitizen. Follow me there.
Interesting
- A restaurant worker's certainty about that evening anchors the Cowboy's Smokehouse video.
- Russell Brand tied Kirk's lobbying against war to his death — see Israel's Iran war push.
- An offer to probe foreign involvement was reportedly rebuffed, per the Joe Kent account.