Trial Cursor — Where The Case Is Right Now
Tyler Robinson is charged, not convicted, and is presumed innocent. Nothing on this page states as fact that any living person committed a crime, destroyed evidence, or acted improperly. Court filings in this case are subject to a gag order and sealing, so the public record is incomplete by design.
Where The Case Stands Right Now
As of September 1, 2026, State of Utah v. Tyler Robinson, Case No. 251403576, is at the last step before the decision on whether the case is bound over for trial.
Bind-over oral argument is being heard today. Judge Graf set aside four hours for it, at 10:00 a.m. MDT in Provo. The five-day preliminary hearing closed on July 10, 2026; rather than take closings from the bench, the court set a written briefing schedule — State first, defense in response, State in rebuttal — and reserved today for argument. No bind-over ruling has issued as of this page's date.
The State has asked the court to bind Robinson over on all seven counts. The defense position, as reported, is that the State did not establish probable cause on the elements that make the charge capital — in particular that the defendant knowingly created a risk of death to anyone other than Charlie Kirk — and that much of what the State relies on is hearsay that was never cross-examined. Those are the two questions in front of the judge today.
| Court | Fourth District Court, Provo |
| Judge | Tony F. Graf Jr. |
| Case number | 251403576 |
| Last completed stage | Preliminary hearing, July 6-10, 2026. The State rested on July 10. |
| Current stage | Bind-over briefing. |
| Current date on calendar | September 1, 2026 — today — bind-over oral argument, four hours reserved |
| Bind-over ruling | Not issued as of September 1, 2026 |
| Trial date | None set |
| Custody status | Held without bail since September 2025 |
| Publicity posture | Broad gag order since December 16, 2025; key forensic material sealed |
What That Means For Everything In This Section
This is the single most important fact for reading the rest of this section fairly, and it is stated on every page here.
The case has not been bound over. Most of the steps this section describes are trial-phase or post-bind-over steps. Expert notice is not due. Motions in limine are not due. Spoliation is a trial remedy. An alternative-perpetrator notice is filed after arraignment on an information, not before a probable-cause finding.
So when a page here says a step is "not visible on the public record," that is a statement about timing as much as about strategy. A step that is not yet due has not been missed.
The steps that are genuinely available now, and that would be visible if taken, are the discovery-side ones: records demands, subpoenas duces tecum to private parties, motions to compel, and sanctions practice. Those are the pages worth reading first.
The Cursor Moves
When the bind-over ruling issues, the cursor moves and roughly half of this section changes status at once:
- If bound over — arraignment on the information, a scheduling order, Rule 16 discovery in full, expert notice deadlines, motions in limine, suppression hearings, then jury selection. Nearly every "still fully open" row in this section becomes live and dated.
- If not bound over — the charges fail at probable cause and the entire section becomes a historical record of a case that ended before trial.
Stage-By-Stage Position
| # | Stage | Dates | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Killing and scene handling | Sept 10-20, 2025 | Complete — scene altered before defense access |
| 2 | Charging and first appearance | Sept 16, 2025 | Complete |
| 3 | Early pretrial dockets | Sept 23, Nov 20, 2025 | Complete |
| 4 | Gag order | Dec 16, 2025 | Complete |
| 5 | Sealing fight over the ATF report | Mar 10, 2026 | Complete |
| 6 | Camera and publicity motions | May 8, 2026 | Complete |
| 7 | Contempt ruling | June 2026 | Complete |
| 8 | Preliminary hearing | July 6-10, 2026 | Complete — State rested |
| 9 | Bind-over briefing and argument | Sept 1, 2026 — being heard today | ← the cursor is here. No ruling issued |
| 10 | Arraignment and scheduling order | If bound over | Not reached |
| 11 | Discovery, expert notice, motions in limine | If bound over | Not reached |
| 12 | Suppression hearings | If bound over | Not reached |
| 13 | Trial — guilt phase | No date | Not reached |
| 14 | Trial — penalty phase | No date | Not reached |
| 15 | Appeal | — | Not reached |
Related
- Days in Court — every reported court date
- Preliminary Hearing transcripts
- How the files here track each stage
- The checklist
- The Day-One Track — what a defense retained on September 12, 2025 would have served, and when
- Two Tracks Compared — the counterfactual against the visible record
This page is a theoretical exercise. It is a written simulation of how an idealised defense attorney might approach this case. We make no claim that there is any problem with the current defense attorney, with any member of the defense team, or with any decision they have made.
Real capital defense is conducted under a gag order, with sealed filings, and on the basis of full discovery that the public has never seen. Counsel of record know facts we do not. A step described here as "not on the public record" may already have been taken privately, may have been considered and rejected for good reason, or may not yet be due at this stage of the case. Silence in the public record is not evidence of a failure.
Nothing here is legal advice, a criticism of any licensed attorney, or an allegation of professional misconduct.
This website's author is @HolonCitizen on X and YouTube/@HolonCitizen. Follow me there.