Skip to main content

Output Analysis: Law 3 - Require Investigation

Does the Law Meet the Human Requirements?​

Requirement: FBI and law enforcement are required to investigate​

MET. Section 2 mandates a full investigation with dedicated team, budget, and timeline. "Shall" creates a legal obligation.

Requirement: US intelligence is required to investigate​

MET. Section 3 mandates a parallel intelligence assessment directed by the DNI, specifically investigating Schedule A intelligence items.

Requirement: Broadly investigate any and all leads​

MET. Section 1(c) defines "good-faith investigation" to include pursuing all leads from Schedule A. Section 2(d) enumerates 8 mandatory investigation categories with specific leads. Section 6(b) gives the monitor authority to direct pursuit of neglected leads.

Requirement: Include the 175 items as mandatory investigation targets​

MET. Section 2(d) specifically enumerates leads from the 175 items organized into categories (exploding microphone, foreign intelligence, cover-up evidence, alternative shooter, financial connections, psychological operations, pre-planning, electronic warfare). Section 8(d) requires each report to address all 175 items.

Requirement: Any government employee may send information​

MET. Section 5(a) allows any government employee to provide information to investigation teams, Trusted Investigators, or the public.

Requirement: Illegal to persecute employees for participating​

MET. Section 5(b-c) makes retaliation unlawful with criminal penalties, reinstatement, and treble damages.

Key Improvements Over Previous Version​

FeaturePreviousCurrent
Scope of investigationGeneral "all leads"175 items as mandatory investigation targets
MonitorCongressional inspector (optional)Independent external monitor (mandatory)
Conflict of interestNot addressedAutomatic transfer to independent commission (Section 4(c))
Schedule A integrationNone8 enumerated investigation categories from 175 items
Report requirementsGeneralMust address each of 175 items individually
Good-faith definitionGeneral principlesExplicitly includes pursuing all Schedule A leads

Potential Problems​

Problem 1: Self-Investigation Conflict​

FBI and intelligence agencies mandated to investigate a case where they may be implicated. Mitigation: Section 4(c) creates automatic conflict-of-interest trigger transferring authority to independent commission. This is a major improvement over the previous version.

Problem 2: Sandbagging​

Agencies can technically comply without pursuing the hardest leads. Mitigation: The external monitor (Section 6) has real-time access and authority to direct pursuit of neglected leads. Mandatory Schedule A reporting in Section 8(d) creates accountability.

Problem 3: Predetermined Conclusions​

Investigations can be structured to reach desired conclusions. Mitigation: Section 1(c) explicitly prevents predetermined conclusions. Section 4 prohibits directing investigators to exclude theories. Monitor certifies good-faith compliance.

Problem 4: Appropriations​

$10M budget and 20-agent team requires appropriations. Recommendation: Include as mandatory appropriation or redirect from existing budgets.

Recommendations​

  1. Consider adding forensic audit requirements for agency systems (coordinate with Law 1)
  2. Strengthen monitor's authority with subpoena power
  3. Add provision requiring investigators to specifically address each of the 175 items in Schedule A
  4. Coordinate with Law 4 so Trusted Investigators can share findings with the investigation team